Potbelly Menu With Prices: Sandwiches, Salads, Soups, Shakes

The Potbelly menu revolves around the toasted sandwich. The menu leads with warm, made-to-order sandwiches — from the meat-packed A Wreck® and Italian to chicken, turkey, roast beef, vegetarian and specialty builds — and fills in around them with salads, wraps, soups, mac and cheese, chips, cookies, shakes and drinks. Many sandwiches come in Skinny and Big sizes as well as the Original, so you can match the portion to your appetite. Short answer: Sandwiches are the core (Skinny $6.89–$8.99, Original $9.19–$11.99, Big $12.19–$15.39 in the reference listing below), joined by wraps, four salads, Pick-your-Pair combos, soups and mac & cheese (from $6.59+), chips, fresh-baked cookies and hand-dipped shakes. Prices here are based on recently available Potbelly ordering information and can change with restaurant location, ordering platform, taxes, promotions and menu updates. Current ordering menus organize the range into sandwiches, wraps, salads, Pick-your-Pair meals, mac and soups, chips and sides, cookies and shakes, and drinks.

Sandwiches on the Potbelly Menu

Sandwiches are the biggest part of the food menu. Current listings show three common size choices for many of them: Skinny, Original, and Big. The exact selection and price can vary by location.

The prices in this table come from a current Potbelly Toast ordering page for a Chicago location. That menu gives Skinny, Original, and Big prices for each of the sandwiches above.

The Sandwiches People Order Most

A Wreck® is one of Potbelly's signature meat-filled sandwiches, stacking turkey breast, hickory-smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami and Swiss cheese.

Italian layers salami, old-world capicola, pepperoni, mortadella and provolone for a rich, Italian-style sandwich.

Chicken Club is grilled chicken with applewood-smoked bacon and cheddar.

Avo Turkey pairs hand-sliced turkey breast and Swiss with fresh avocado and cucumbers.

Mediterranean combines grilled chicken, feta, hummus, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and cucumbers — and the menu notes this sandwich can be made vegetarian.

Mama's Meatball uses homestyle beef and pork meatballs with marinara sauce, provolone and Italian seasoning.

Pizza Melt is the pizza-inspired build: pepperoni, capicola, meatball, marinara, provolone, Italian seasoning and mushrooms where available.

Prime Rib Steak is sliced prime rib steak with Swiss cheese, caramelized onions and garlic aioli; hot peppers can be added for extra heat.

Street Corn Chicken features grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, Mexican-style street corn and smoky ancho chile sauce.

Fiery Island Chicken combines grilled chicken and provolone with fiery jerk sauce and fresh-sliced avocado.

Wraps

Potbelly also offers sandwiches as wraps, along with dedicated wrap choices. Current delivery menus list two prominent specialty wraps.

Prices for both wraps vary by location — current delivery listings show different prices in different cities, so do not treat these amounts as a national fixed price. The Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap is the straightforward one: grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar, vegetables and ranch. The Southwest Avo Chicken Wrap leans Southwest with avocado, tortilla crisps and chipotle-lime sauce. Potbelly also suggests going easy on additional toppings on wraps so they stay easier to eat.

Salads

If you would rather skip the toasted sandwich, the menu has several substantial salads built around greens, vegetables, proteins, cheese, fruit and dressings.

These prices are representative delivery prices and vary among Potbelly locations. The four salad varieties and their ingredient combinations are confirmed by current listings.

Farmhouse Salad

A hearty mix — grilled chicken, bacon, blue cheese, egg, cucumber and tomatoes over field greens — served with creamy buttermilk ranch.

Apple Walnut Salad

Grilled chicken, blue cheese, grapes, apples, dried cranberries and candied walnuts, dressed with balsamic vinaigrette.

Powerhouse Salad

Grilled chicken with fresh avocado, hummus, hard-boiled egg, cucumber and tomatoes over field greens; the listed dressing is a fat-free vinaigrette.

Pick-your-Pair Combinations

Pick-your-Pair lets you combine smaller portions from different categories. On current menus, the combinations involve a Skinny sandwich, a half salad, soup, chili, or mac and cheese.

The exact price depends on the Potbelly location and ordering channel. The format is useful when you want two different menu items instead of one full-sized entrée.

Mac & Cheese and Soups

The soups and comfort-food options complement the sandwich menu. Current menus list mac and cheese plus soups including Chicken Pot Pie, Broccoli Cheddar, Chili, Garden Vegetable, and Loaded Baked Potato.

The Chicken Pot Pie Soup is a creamy comfort-food option with slow-roasted chicken and vegetables. The Broccoli Cheddar Soup pairs broccoli and carrots in a creamy cheese base. The Chili uses beef, kidney beans, bell peppers, and onions. Mac & Cheese, described on current menus as a creamy three-cheese mac, works as a side or a smaller comfort-food meal.

Chips and Sides

Potbelly offers several packaged chip choices, plus meal-style combinations that pair chips with a drink or a shake.

Current DoorDash menu data lists these chip and meal-combination options, although prices vary between stores and ordering platforms. Some locations also list a Potbelly Whole Pickle and a jar of the restaurant's hot peppers as additional options. On a current Alexandria delivery menu, the whole pickle is priced at $1.69 and a hot-pepper jar at $8.79.

Cookies and Shakes

The sweet side of the menu: freshly baked cookies, dessert bars, hand-dipped shakes and larger cookie packs.

Current delivery menus list these cookies and shakes, with exact prices changing by location. The Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie, described as a Potbelly favorite, is baked fresh. The Dream Bar combines chocolatey oatmeal with caramel. The hand-dipped shakes include traditional flavors such as chocolate, vanilla and strawberry as well as specialty choices such as OREO®, cold brew, banana pudding and English toffee.

Drinks and Beverages

The beverage selection includes bottled soft drinks, water, sparkling water and other bottled choices. Some locations also offer fountain drinks.

The current DoorDash menu lists these beverages, while another Potbelly ordering menu shows fountain drinks at separate prices. Availability and pricing can therefore differ between stores.

Making a Sandwich Your Own

Potbelly gives you several ways to customize. Depending on the item and location, you can add or remove toppings, change cheeses, add meat or select sauces. Current ordering information lists toppings such as mayo, deli mustard, hot peppers, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, pickles, cucumbers, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, ranch, Hot Pepper Ranch, Sweet Heat BBQ, red wine vinegar and roasted garlic aioli.

Additional ingredients may cost extra. Current ordering information shows optional additions such as bacon, mushrooms, avocado, double meat, double cheese, pepperoni, salami, capicola and mortadella. The Mediterranean sandwich is specifically listed as one that can be made vegetarian, but anyone with allergies or specific dietary requirements should check ingredients and preparation procedures directly with their local Potbelly restaurant.

Why Prices Differ by Location

One of the most important things to remember when checking Potbelly menu prices is that there is no single nationwide price for every item. Current delivery menus price the same sandwiches differently in different cities — the Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap and Southwest Avo Chicken Wrap, for example, appear at different prices on different location-specific menus.

What you pay for delivery can also differ from pickup or in-store prices. DoorDash specifically points out that its displayed prices may vary by store and that delivery or platform pricing can differ from what you see elsewhere. For the most accurate Potbelly prices, select your local restaurant before ordering.

Popular Choices

The menu covers several different styles of meal, so the best choice depends on what you are after.

• A Wreck® — a meat-heavy signature sandwich with turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, and Swiss.
• Italian — a classic combination of salami, capicola, pepperoni, mortadella, and provolone.
• Chicken Club — grilled chicken with bacon and cheddar.
• Mediterranean — grilled chicken, feta, hummus, artichokes, roasted red peppers, and cucumbers.
• Prime Rib Steak — steak with Swiss, caramelized onions, and garlic aioli.
• Farmhouse Salad — a protein-rich salad with chicken, bacon, blue cheese, egg, vegetables, and ranch.
• Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap — a wrap built around grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar, vegetables, and ranch.
• Chicken Pot Pie Soup — a warm soup featuring chicken and vegetables.
• Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie — a freshly baked dessert option.
• Hand-Dipped Shakes — available in traditional and specialty flavors.

Final Thoughts

Potbelly offers considerably more than toasted sandwiches. Signature meat sandwiches such as A Wreck®, Italian, Chicken Club, Prime Rib Steak and Mama's Meatball headline the main menu, alongside turkey, chicken, roast beef, tuna, vegetarian and specialty options — plus wraps, salads, soups, mac and cheese, chips, freshly baked cookies and hand-dipped shakes.

If you are researching Potbelly menu prices, the most important point is that prices are location-specific. The figures in this guide provide current reference pricing from available Potbelly ordering menus, but the final amount can change based on the restaurant, size, customization, taxes and ordering method. Checking the selected local restaurant before ordering is the best way to confirm current Potbelly food menu items and prices.

Frequently asked questions

Keep reading

• All general calculators
• Popeyes Menu With Prices 2026: Chicken, Sandwiches and Sides
• Panda Express Menu With Prices 2026: Entrées, Sides, Plates
• Noodles and Company Menu With Prices: Pasta, Mac and Bowls
• Mellow Mushroom Menu With Prices 2026: Pizzas, Hoagies, Wings